Staff Picks: And China Has Hands

Celia recommends And China Has Hands by H.T. Tsiang:

Here’s a book I was delighted to discover, reprinted in a lovely edition by Kaya Press: And China Has Hands, by H.T. Tsiang. It’s something of an unrecognized classic: written in 1937, it follows two Chinese Americans living in New York City. The heroes of the novel are Wong Wan-Lee and Pearl Chang (who Tsiang always refers to by their full names, never by a given name alone). Wong Wan-Lee is a recent immigrant from China in New York City, the son of a naturalized American citizen, who, having barely escaped an illegal deportation, buys the lease to a laundry business in order to try and pay off his legal fees. He’s a dreamer, a little bewildered by the country he’s immigrated to, but street smart in a gentle way. When a group of white school boys taunt him outside his laundry, he throws them some fruit and hopes to make friends. When various New York bureaucrats try to pressure him into paying bribes or protection money, he takes refuge in pretending that he doesn’t speak English. He can’t pay if he can’t understand, and he hopes this will protect him.

Pearl Chang, on the other hand, has grown up in the American South, the child of a Chinese father and a black mother. Having lived under segregation, she’s used to concealing her mixed-race heritage, in the hope of avoiding the worst anti-black sentiments thrown at her. She’s an outspoken would-be actress, and she and Wong Wan-Lee meet when she takes his side when he’s being harassed outside of his laundry. He quickly falls in a kind of love with her. It’s the 1930s, after all, when Chinese women were severely restricted from immigrating to the United States, a policy intended to prevent the Chinese men who came to build railroads or work in America’s cities from building communities and putting down roots in their adopted country.

As a result, Wong Wan-Lee barely knows any Chinese women in New York, and, lonely as he is, his feelings for Pearl Chang teeter between love and obsession. She likes him back for his gentleness, which is different from the white men she’s known, who have harassed her or treated her badly, and for the connection she feels with her father’s homeland, which she’s never been to. But while Wong Wan-Lee feels immediately connected with Pearl Chang, he’s also a little ashamed of her. She exoticizes him, imagining him as a foreign prince, and he takes her very American habits for evidence that she’s a bit of a fool. When they go out together, she sometimes teases him with the same racial slurs that his white customers use, and he refuses to hold her hand or walk beside her, lest anyone guess that they’re a couple.

Their elliptical, unsteady romance plays out against the backdrop of Depression-Era Manhattan, which seems at first to be a world in which anyone can make it—from laundry worker to millionaire, or waitress to movie star. But the game is rigged in ways that aren’t at first visible to the naked eye. Tsiang uses a light touch in painting the social and economic struggles that his heroes experience—he spends as much time on the intricacies of Wong Wan-Lee’s friendship with his cat as on his decision to make a deal with a loan shark—but slowly, the noose tightens, and Wong Wan-Lee and Pearl Chang descend into harder, more straightened circumstances.

Tsiang himself was a radical and a performer, a devoted Communist who worked as the secretary to the secretary of Sun Yat-sen, played bit parts in a dozen odd films, including the original Ocean’s Eleven, wrote and staged his own plays, and remained deeply involved with the leftist movement after immigrating to the United States. Having fled China in 1926, after his radical politics got him into trouble, he enrolled at Columbia University, only to face recurring problems with his student visa that nearly saw him deported under the Chinese Exclusion Act. In his original introduction to And China Has Hands, he credits the ACLU and the International Labor Defense with the legal aid that allowed him to remain in the United States.

Tsiang self-published a number of books before finally convincing a commercial publishing house to take a chance on And China Has Hands, a piece of autobiography that Tsiang turns into a good-natured joke on himself in one of the novel’s minor characters: a charming but rather hapless and self-absorbed “proletarian” novelist, who self-publishes his work and keeps getting kicked out of restaurants for trying to hand-sell copies of his book to pay his printing bill. Near the end, he finally secures a publisher—who, learning that he plans to attend a restaurant workers’ strike (at one of the restaurants that has tossed him out), keenly hopes that “the author would get his head clubbed so his picture would appear in the papers and, by-productingly, his books be mentioned.” Tsiang’s own publishers don’t seem to have taken offense, although they did, perhaps somewhat backhandedly, refer to his “[rather startling] artless habit of calling a spade by its given name” in their jacket copy for the original book.

Tsiang’s contemporary critics also seem to have not entirely known what to make of him. In his afterword to Kaya Press’s edition of And China Has Hands, Floyd Cheung quotes one reviewer’s assessment that Tsiang’s written English was “functional and surprisingly effective, though not always ‘correct.’” In reading Tsiang, I was pleasantly reminded of the prose of Barbara Comyns, another rather brilliant prose stylist whose writing was dismissively received in her time as a kind of naïve art—and who takes a similarly fresh, playful, irrepressibly hopeful tone even when describing situations of acute isolation and hardship.

The simplicity of Tsiang’s sentences is deceptive. Throughout the novel, the straightforward, declarative way that Tsiang writes out his characters’ hopes, fears and dreams conceals the careful eye with which he captures the wider social and political context of his world. Their lives are not only their lives, but the precious components of the collective to which Tsiang devoted his work as an activist. Excluded from power, their lives are still invisibly and inexorably shaped by the actions of the rich and powerful around them. If Tsiang’s hopes for a world that is more just to the poor, to immigrants, and to refugees have not yet been realized, his work remains all the more relevant today for the clarity with which it foresees the questions of justice and belonging that the United States is still struggling to address.

NYRB Classics Spotlight: The Go-Between

Malvern staff member Fernando is a New York Review Books Classics enthusiast, and he has an excellent recommendation for y’all…

The Go-Between by L.P. Hartley

This is my idea of a summer novel: English, pastoral, bildungsroman, filled with secret love affairs, in a twentieth-century setting well before the outbreak of the First World War. Told in multiple layers, it is witty, deep, and at times heart-wrenching—what visions of the future the world held for us then.

Also recommended: The Fountain Overflows by Rebecca West. Growing up with talented siblings in early twentieth-century London is not easy, but it certainly is picaresque and strange.